|
Bourdieu, Schneidermann
and Journalisme :
Analysis of a Counter-critique
by Pascal
Fortin
In Sur la télévision (On Television), a slim red
volume published in 1996, the French sociologist Pierre Bourdieu delivers
a highly-charged polemic on television and on journalism. Just over two
years later, Daniel Schneiderman - columnist at Le Monde, the
French daily of record, and host of a television programme dedicated to
decrypting the "little image factory" - makes a first
attempt to refute Bourdieu's theses with Du journalisme
après Bourdieu.
What makes his analysis so disappointing? And why is it so unconvincing?
This article tries to answer these questions, starting not only
with an internal analysis of Schneiderman's book, but also by taking
into account the context in which it was published.
Anxious to rehabilitate a profession which, in his eyes, has been
made victim of a veritable media lynching, Daniel Schneiderman instead
winds up with eloquent testimony, both to the pertinence of the
Bourdieusian critique which he had thought to demolish, and to his own
inability to distance himself from a professional mythology without
which Schneiderman appears incapable of finding "meaning"
in his journalistic activities.
Keywords: Bourdieu, Schneidermann, television, journalism,
sociology, connivance, censorship, deontology.
© 2000 - Pascal
Fortin - All rights
reserved.
( Résumé | Resumen | Resümee )

Internet Users' Representation
of Temporality
by Luc
Bonneville
With the generalized and recurrent domestic use of New
Information and Communication Technologies (NICT), society's
computerization is changing the daily practices of a
growing proportion of the population. The wide-spread use
of NICTs implies a number of changes in the social construction
of time and, by corollary, in the representation of time more
generally. Based on a research project undertaken for a master's
program in sociology, this article suggests that these new
representations of temporality require us to completely
reexamine the temporal framework objectified by modernity
since its beginnings. It tries, first, to examine what this
upheaval of "time" consists of inside the framework
of recurrent Internet use, and second, to look at how the
individual's relationships with time and with space place
the question of the chronothesis directly into play. In so
doing, the article questions the phenomenological basis of
time's new representations in the context of NICT deployment.
Keywords : Temporality, chronothesis, representation,
space, Internet .
© 2000 - Luc
Bonneville - All
rights reserved.
( Résumé | Resumen | Resümee )

Gilbert
Simondon's Contribution to the Study of Technology
by Élisabeth
Gladu
This article's goal is to present Gilbert Simondon's contribution
to the study of technology. After having shown the ways in which
his ideas remain relevant today, the article establishes several
connections between Simondon's and more recent theories of the
technological object, examining Simondon's doctoral thesis, entitled
Du mode d'existence des objets techniques. The article
starts by outlining first principles as well as the postulates upon
which Simondon's thesis rests, before examining the concept of
individuation. Moving to the later chapters of the thesis, the
article attempts to facilitate understanding by presenting
the genesis of the modes of thinking and of being-in-the-world
that constitute a generalized genetic interpretation of the
human being's relations with the world at large.
Keywords : Gilbert Simondon, technophobia, culture, individuation,
technology, philosophy, genesis.
© 2000 - Élisabeth
Gladu - All rights
reserved.
( Résumé | Resumen | Resümee )

The Internet Relay
Chat :
An Exemplary Sociotechnical Dispositif
par Guillaume
Latzko-Toth
Internet Relay Chat (IRC) is a sociotechnical dispositif
(apparatus) whose interface takes the form of a synchronous,
text-based, distributed teleconferencing system, based on an
open protocol. It is probably the Internet application most
commonly used to practice what, in the English language, is
referred to as "chat". Looking beyond the attention
often paid to the ludic, or playful, aspects of this form of
electronic sociability, this article attempts to analyse it
as a case which, in the author's opinion, exemplifies an application
of the Internet protocol, thereby showing how IRC helps shed
light upon the larger parameters of the relationship between
the social and technological. Developed through a collaborative
process, the technical protocol underlying IRC has, in a decade
of existence, been the object of numerous adaptations and variations,
parallelling the explosion in its user base. This article attempts
to analyse the dispositif according to two perspectives,
one synchronic, the other diachronic. In the first, we present
the IRC's functional characteristics from both technical and
social standpoints, showing how this communicational space is
the object of complex relations of power, of which some are
inscribed at the technical level itself. In the second, we examine
the main steps involved in the sociotechnical development of
IRC over time, bringing into sharper focus the structuring role
of communication practices in the modification, even reinvention,
of the technological artifact, and by extension, the relative
erasure of boundaries between designers and users.
Keywords : sociotechnical dispositif, sociotechnical
apparatus, computer-mediated communication, network, Internet,
IRC, chat, social uses, technological practice, appropriation.
© 2000 - Guillaume
Latzko-Toth - All
rights reserved.
( Résumé | Resumen | Resümee )

Media Communication
Studies in Québec and the Cultural Studies Approach
by François
Yelle
This article is intended to propose several research questions to
help examine the limited circulation of Cultural Studies in the field of
university-based research on media communications in Québec. Using
his academic biography as a starting point, the author explains his
interest in Cultural Studies (CS) and offers a brief description of the
CS project. The article then briefly reviews the social sciences'
beginnings in Québec, summarising the special characteristics which
led to the founding of communications departments. Then, following a short
presentation of early Québécois research on culture,
particularly through the political economy of cultural industries,
the first Québécois articles to comment upon CS are
identified and discussed.
The article attempts to underline and to comment upon the
"asynchronous" circulation of ideas between French-language
and English-language worlds, carrying the discussion into an overview
of the critiques of CS formulated and circulated within media
studies. Finally, the article concludes with a call for discussion,
hoping to shake loose the reasons for the failure of the CS approach
to noticeably "seduce" students and scholars toward this approach
to communication studies.
Keywords : Cultural Studies, media studies, communication studies,
culture, Québécois research, Québec.
© 2000 - François
Yelle - All rights
reserved.
( Résumé | Resumen | Resümee )

© Les éditions électroniques
COMMposite - 2000 - All rights reserved..
|